ACCEPTING CASES · MON–FRI 9:00AM–5:00PM
Certified Data Recovery Professional · Phoenix, AZ ☎ (602) 686-2622

Your Encrypted Time Machine Drive Won't Work in macOS 28. Don't Erase It.

Apple is dropping support for encrypted Mac OS Extended (HFS+) volumes in macOS 28. If your Time Machine backup drive was set up encrypted on an older Mac, it is probably one of them, and Apple's convert and decrypt fixes do not apply to backup disks. The safe move is a second drive, not erasing the first.

Free evaluation · No data, no fee · Talk directly with a technician.

A backup drive is usually the copy people stop thinking about. This change puts a deadline on some of them, and the obvious fix, letting Time Machine erase the old disk and start over, throws away years of history that may be the only copy of files deleted long ago.

What Apple changed

The macOS 27 release notes list it as a deprecation: "Encrypted HFS+ (CoreStorage) is deprecated and will not be supported in a future version of macOS. If you use Encrypted HFS+ backups on external drives, begin backing up to encrypted APFS-formatted external drives instead."

Apple's support article, "About support for encrypted Mac OS Extended disks in macOS 28 or later" (published July 22, 2026), names the version: in macOS 28 and later, Mac OS Extended will be supported only for volumes that aren't encrypted. Unencrypted HFS+ keeps working. APFS and APFS Encrypted are not affected. Apple's Time Machine backup disk page points owners of encrypted older backup disks to the same article.

Apple has not given a release date for macOS 28, and we will not guess one.

Check your drive. It's read-only.

  1. Connect the backup drive and unlock it with its password if asked.
  2. Open Disk Utility. From the View menu, choose Show Only Volumes.
  3. Select the backup volume and read the line under its name. If it shows both "Mac OS Extended" and "Encrypted", it is affected. Apple's example reads CoreStorage Logical Volume • Mac OS Extended (Case-sensitive, Journaled, Encrypted).

Looking does not change anything. Do not click First Aid, Erase, or anything in the Edit menu while you are there.

Why the backup drive is the exception

For a regular encrypted HFS+ data drive, Apple offers three options: convert it to encrypted APFS, decrypt it, or copy the data off and reformat. For Time Machine disks, Apple says plainly that convert and decrypt don't apply.

The reason is how the old backups are built. Time Machine on HFS+ relies on directory hard links, and APFS doesn't support them. Time Machine on APFS uses snapshots instead. The Eclectic Light Company explains that there is no way to carry an HFS+ backup history over to APFS, and that trying an in-place conversion on a Time Machine disk is high risk and unlikely to succeed. That leaves one path: close out the old backup and start a new one.

What to do, in this order

  1. Get a second drive. Do not reuse the old backup disk as the new one.
  2. Add it as an encrypted backup disk. In Time Machine settings, click Add Backup Disk, pick the new drive, and turn on encryption. Apple calls APFS or APFS Encrypted the preferred format, and Time Machine offers to erase and reformat a disk that isn't APFS already. That erase is fine on the new drive. It is the one you must not accept on the old drive.
  3. Let the first full backup finish, then open Time Machine and confirm you can browse it.
  4. Label the old drive and keep it. Write down which Mac it belonged to and where the password lives. Store the password somewhere you will still have in five years, such as a password manager.
  5. Plan how you will read it later. Apple's change is for macOS 28 and later. If you might need something from the old history after your Mac moves to macOS 28, keep access to a Mac that runs macOS 27 or earlier, or restore what you care about to the new backup before you upgrade.

This is the same rule we use everywhere: prove the new copy before you retire the old one. Windows users have their own version of it in File History stopped, don't wipe the backup drive.

Your encrypted backup drive stopped mounting, or someone already erased or converted it. Stop using it. Every new write lands on the history you are trying to get back.

The mistakes we expect to see

When it really is a recovery case

The deprecation does not damage anything, but old backup drives do fail, and they tend to get noticed when someone finally goes looking. If the drive clicks, disconnects, or doesn't show up at all, see external drive not recognized and clicking hard drives, and stop powering it on. If it was already erased or a conversion was started, unplug it so nothing else writes, and write down exactly what ran.

With the password, an encrypted volume is something we can work on: we image the drive first and work from the image, never from the original. Without the password, we stop, and we will tell you that up front. What is recoverable depends on the drive and on what was already done to it, and we find that out in the evaluation before you owe anything. The public case log has no encrypted Time Machine disk, and we will not invent one. We don't advertise a success rate.

Pack it the way any failed drive is packed, with a note of what macOS showed and anything anyone tried. Arizona drop-off is on the locations page. Everywhere else is mail-in. The work is Mac data recovery and external hard drive data recovery. The phone number on this site is (602) 686-2622, Mon–Fri 9:00am–5:00pm.

Encrypted Time Machine and macOS 28 FAQ

Does macOS 27 already stop reading my encrypted Time Machine drive?
No. macOS 27 lists encrypted HFS+ (CoreStorage) as deprecated, which is a warning. Apple's support article says the format will be supported only for unencrypted volumes in macOS 28 and later. Starting with macOS 26, your Mac may show a notification naming the affected volume. That notification is not a sign anything is wrong with the drive.
Is an unencrypted HFS+ Time Machine drive affected?
No. Apple says macOS 28 and later will continue to support unencrypted Mac OS Extended volumes. Only the combination of Mac OS Extended and Encrypted is affected. APFS and APFS Encrypted backup disks are not part of the change.
Can I just click Convert to APFS on the backup drive?
Apple says that solution "doesn't apply to encrypted Time Machine backup disks," and the same line appears under Decrypt. Older Time Machine backups on HFS+ are built on directory hard links, which APFS does not have, so as The Eclectic Light Company puts it, there is no way to migrate the history and an in-place conversion of a backup is high risk. Leave the old disk as it is and start a new one.
I forgot the password to the old backup drive. Can you get around it?
No. Without the password, the backup is ciphertext, and the encryption is doing its job. We can help when the drive itself has failed and you have the password. We cannot help you guess one, and we will tell you so before you ship anything.
Is there an encrypted Time Machine case in your public case log?
No. The public case log includes a dead LaCie external with an HFS+ volume that we rebuilt after a firmware fix, but no encrypted Time Machine disk. We will not invent one, and we don't advertise a success rate.

An encrypted HFS+ Time Machine drive isn't broken because macOS 28 is coming. Keep it and start a new backup. If the old drive has failed or was already erased, start with a free evaluation.

Request free evaluation →

Free evaluation · No data, no fee · Talk directly with a technician.